PHILLIPSTON — At present, Auburn and Clinton are the only municipalities in central Massachusetts with a dual tax rate — that is, one rate for residential and personal property, and another for commercial property. One Phillipston resident is wondering if that town should become the third.
Chuck Kolbenson sparked a discussion of the issue at the Phillipston Selectboard meeting on Wednesday, Jan. 26, by suggesting voters at this year’s Annual Town Meeting weigh in on the issue.
Phillipston currently charges the same rate for residential and commercial/industrial properties. According to the state Department of Revenue Division of Local Services Bureau of Accounts, Phillipston’s tax rate for FY22 stands at $15.58 per $1,000 in valuation. Residential property taxes account for a bit over $3.6 million of the town’s budget of nearly $3.9 million, while personal property taxes add another $112,000. Commercial properties contribute just over $116,000, while industrial properties kick in approximately $10,000.
“I’d like to request that I be able to put an article on the warrant to increase the commercial property tax rate and decrease the residential property tax rate,” Kolbenson told the board.
In response to a question from board member Gerhard Fandreyer, Kolbenson said he was unsure exactly how many commercial properties would be affected by a tax hike.
“Apparently, Chuck did some research,” said board Chair Bernie Malouin, “and what he’s suggesting is to raise (the tax rate) another quarter percent for the commercial, and whatever that amount comes to, deduct it on the residential side. The residential would go down — probably not much because there’s not that much commercial in town.
“The thinking, I guess, in what I was reading, is there’s no mercy from the cable or utility companies when it comes to raising rates on the people in Phillipston. This would be a way of getting back some of the money the taxpayers are paying through their services, like cable, telephone, and electricity.”
Malouin then offered some clarification, noting that consumers wouldn’t pay any less on their utility bills. What would result, he said, is that utility companies would pay a bigger property tax bill while residents’ tax bills would be reduced by a corresponding amount.
“It would be everybody that has a commercial property in Phillipston,” he said, “including Verizon, National Grid, and whoever else owns the utilities poles, because every utility pole is supposed to pay a fee, or taxes, to Phillipston.”
Kolbenson explained further that the three utility companies would not be the only ones paying increased taxes.
“It affects businesses throughout the town,” he added. “That’s the intent — all the businesses. The assessors say it’s not possible to do just selected businesses, like ones with over 100 employees, for example. And I have not been able to find anywhere in the state where that has been done — where they’ve been able to differentiate. So, it has to be all businesses.”
Malouin then asked the other two members of the board if they should consider placing an article on the town warrant seeking a vote on a dual tax system.
Finance Committee Chair Tom Specht expressed concern a tax increase would hit the smallest businesses in town the hardest.
“Have you done any kind of a study to see how much more money is going to be brought in and affect the residential taxes on the people — the rate?” he asked Kolbenson. “Is it going to be a hundred-thousand, 200, 300, a half-million, or is it going to be $90,000.”
While he didn’t have the figures at hand, Kolbenson said he has asked the assessors what the difference would be.
“If it isn’t a sizable amount of money, that would be a reason not to bother,” he said.
“Just keep this mind,” Malouin interjected. “The selectmen do vote for the tax rate. We have a public hearing and vote for that, so that would be the appropriate place to this, would it not, instead of doing it at town meeting? I’m thinking that would be the way to go.”
“I concur 100 percent,” said Kolbenson. “I’d love to see it done that way. I was just trying to have this issue get moved.”
“That’s fine,” replied Malouin. “I understand. But you could still follow up and see if it’s a worthwhile venture.”
The board ultimately voted to table the issue for further discussion at a later meeting.
Greg Vine can be reached at gvineadn@gmail.com
