BOSTON—A judge signaled Tuesday he may hold off on deciding whether the Senate satisfied Auditor Diana DiZoglio’s requests for legislative financial records until after resolving the broader constitutional dispute over her authority to audit the Legislature.

Suffolk Superior Court Judge David Deakin, hearing arguments in DiZoglio’s lawsuit against legislative leaders, suggested the Senate’s motion to dismiss the case as moot could wait until the underlying constitutional questions are resolved.

Tuesday’s hearing centered on whether the Senate’s June production of four categories of financial records fulfilled DiZoglio’s requests, making her lawsuit against Senate officials moot. That question is related to a larger legal issue of whether the 2024 voter-approved law authorizing legislative audits is constitutional. The Senate argues the case should be dismissed because it provided everything DiZoglio requested. The auditor maintains the records are incomplete and that the court must determine whether the Legislature can legally refuse to submit to an audit.

DiZoglio filed a separate motion seeking a ruling in her favor against the House, which has produced no responsive documents.

But the path to those answers will take longer than DiZoglio wants. Deakin scheduled a Dec. 2 hearing on the constitutional dispute involving the House and a separate Jan. 19 hearing for the Senate, after attorneys’ scheduling conflicts prevented the joint proceeding he initially favored.

The split schedule drew an immediate objection from DiZoglio’s attorney, Shannon Liss-Riordan, who warned that lawmakers are simultaneously advancing legislation that could substantially change the audit law — or limit the courts’ ability to enforce it.

After the hearing, DiZoglio described the delay as another effort to prolong a dispute that has been underway for more than two years.

“I’m disappointed that it’s not moving as expeditiously as we would have hoped,” DiZoglio said. She pointed to legislation moving through a conference committee that could reach Gov. Maura Healey’s desk while the court case remains unresolved.

Language in conference combines changes to the public records law with provisions affecting legislative audits. Democratic leaders argued the bill preserves the constitutional separation of powers between the Legislature and the executive branch, of which the auditor’s office is a part. The bill would limit the auditor’s power to investigate the branch to four categories of administrative functions, rather than the more expansive language outlined in the 2024 ballot law.

It also stops Secretary of State William Galvin’s office, which usually oversees public records inquiries, from interfering in requests to the Legislature, but allows a path of judicial review, while simultaneously barring the courts from resolving disputes between the auditor and lawmakers.

The timing is important — lawmakers face a deadline to pass the bill by the end of the legislative session in early January (ahead of the Senate’s Jan. 19 hearing) unless they want to go back to the drawing board at the start of the new session.

Deakin said he did not want to “race the Legislature,” but also emphasized the public’s interest in resolving the dispute promptly.

“I’m not interested in ruining anybody’s vacation,” he said while working through the scheduling conflicts. “On the other hand, I believe all parties, and maybe beyond the parties, the people of the commonwealth, have an interest in seeing these issues resolved in a timely fashion.”

The judge also questioned the Senate’s argument that its June production of records had made the lawsuit moot, particularly given that Senate leaders still want a judicial determination on whether the audit law is constitutional.

At one point, Deakin observed that the Senate appeared to want both to have the case dismissed and to preserve its opportunity to challenge the law.

“You can’t have your cake and eat it too,” he said.

The exchange captured the central tension in Tuesday’s hearing: The Senate says it has given DiZoglio everything she specifically requested and should not have to defend a case over records it has already produced. The auditor says the Senate failed to hand over all the records, and that the Legislature cannot unilaterally decide what constitutes compliance with a law approved by voters.

A question of what was actually produced

The question before Deakin on Tuesday was narrowly confined to four categories of records that DiZoglio requested in January 2025, covering fiscal years 2021 through 2024: official budgets, official audits, transactions involving balance-forward line items and monetary settlement agreements.

The dispute has its roots in the November 2024 passage of Question 1, which authorized the state auditor to audit the Legislature. DiZoglio had first approached House Speaker Ronald Mariano and Senate President Karen Spilka about a performance audit in March 2023. Both declined.

After Question 1 passed, DiZoglio renewed her effort and sent the four-category document request in January 2025. The House did not respond. The Senate raised objections, and the dispute eventually reached the Supreme Judicial Court.

Following a May 7 SJC order limiting the litigation to those four categories, the attorney general authorized the lawsuit on the records requests, but warned against expanding its scope.

The Senate voted May 28 to voluntarily provide the documents while expressly reserving its constitutional objections. Its general counsel, James DiTullio, delivered the records June 1, declaring in a transmittal letter that the Senate had fully responded.

DiZoglio filed a new complaint the following day, alleging the production was “severely deficient.”

Her office’s supporting affidavit, filed by general counsel and Deputy Auditor Michael Leung-Tat, argued that the Senate had provided appropriations rather than actual budgets, incomplete audit materials, lump-sum balance-forward figures rather than transaction listings and no independently verified accounting of settlement agreements.

On Tuesday, attorney Jennifer Grace Miller, outside counsel retained by the Senate, argued that the Legislature had done exactly what the auditor requested.

All parties obtained outside counsel to argue the case in court.

Liss-Riordan is arguing on the auditor’s behalf for free, and the Senate has paid Miller’s firm $63,720 since June, according to state financial records. The House has paid outside counsel Thomas Kiley of CEK Boston $33,951 since his services were retained in January, and has not yet filed financial statements for payment to Meredith Fierro of Butters Brazilian, who the House retained in August.

Spokespeople for the House and Senate both declined to directly answer how much they paid outside counsel for the suit. DiZoglio told the News Service, “We are incredibly grateful to Attorney Shannon Liss-Riordan for representing the People of the Commonwealth on this matter.”

During Tuesday’s hearing, Miller argued that the Senate provided “good faith responses” to all four of the auditor’s requested categories of records.

She said the Senate’s official budget is the annual line item it receives in the General Appropriations Act every year, which is what was presented to DiZoglio’s office.

Unlike executive agencies, the Legislature does not draft a spending plan that actually details how that money is spent, she said. Miller said the Senate had no additional official budget documents to provide.

“That is our official budget. There is nothing else. It may very well be that executive agencies have to produce supporting materials, additional more detailed materials, in order to support their budget request,” Miller said.

She added, “She asked for our official budget, and the official budget is, in fact, the line item for the Senate in the GAA.”

Liss-Riordan countered that an appropriation is not a budget, which ordinarily lays out how an agency plans to spend its money across categories, and there are likely documents that exist that show how the Senate spends its money that it is not handing over.

Deakin called it “unusual” that the Senate would not have a prospective budget, but also questioned why the auditor had not initially made a broader request for all documents related to legislative spending.

Liss-Riordan said the auditor’s office was following the ordinary auditing process, in which requesting an agency’s budget is a standard starting point.

Similarly, Miller said the Senate had no other official audits beyond the materials it produced from its auditing firm, CliftonLarsonAllen.

The distinction between an official audit and the supporting reports referenced within it became a particularly heated point.

“The auditor requested very straightforward terms: the official audit, and that is what we provided to the auditor’s office,” Miller said.

Liss-Riordan argued that the Senate was essentially labeling portions of its financial reporting as audits while withholding more detailed information that would allow the auditor to evaluate its financial practices.

“The audits reference additional reports that were not included in the production. So their own responses refer to other documents that they didn’t produce,” she said.

Deakin pushed Liss-Riordan on this matter, and indicated that it may be a question of legal debate whether the term “audit” means all referenced documentation, but said, “That doesn’t preclude you, I suppose, from amending your complaint” to include requests for the referenced financial statements.

On balance-forward funds, Miller argued that the money is carried into subsequent fiscal years and commingled with other appropriations, making it impossible to trace individual transactions to those funds.

“You just heard the Senate counsel explaining why: ‘Well, this is what we do. We don’t, it’s not really broken down, as it all gets forwarded to the next year.’ That’s exactly what the auditor is looking for: a breakdown of all transactions. So the Senate specifically did not provide what was requested,” Liss-Riordan replied.

Discovery, settlements and the judge’s skepticism

The most contentious exchange involved the auditor’s demand for additional discovery to determine whether the Senate had settlement agreements it claimed did not exist.

The Senate counsel said in an August court filing the auditor was effectively trying to expand her original requests after receiving the documents, and was seeking to use litigation to “conduct her audit through discovery.”

Liss-Riordan disputed that characterization, arguing that the Senate’s own documents reference additional materials that were not provided.

In January 2025, DiZoglio asked for settlement agreements in her list of requests to the Legislature.

Miller maintained that the Senate has no agreements meeting what the auditor requested.

“The auditor requested a very specific type of monetary settlement agreement. She referred to a definition in the comptroller’s office,” Miller said. “The Senate reviewed that definition and reviewed its own files and determined that it did not have any settlement agreements that met that definition. Essentially, the auditor is saying that she would like to test that representation in court.”

Liss-Riordan argued that DiZoglio’s office could not simply accept the Senate’s sworn representations without examining the underlying records. In previous audits, she said, reviewing personnel records had uncovered settlement agreements that agencies had not initially disclosed.

Deakin questioned how far that approach would go, noting that it could effectively require the Senate to open its personnel files to the court.

When Liss-Riordan suggested that targeted discovery might be possible, Deakin cautioned that an auditor’s disbelief in a defendant’s representations does not automatically justify searching through an entire institution’s records.

“The auditor does not believe the Senate that there are none, and is entitled in this litigation system discovery about whether they do exist,” Liss-Rioirdan said.

The judge replied, “So, the auditor’s belief that maybe they’re not telling the truth, or maybe I shouldn’t say not telling the truth, the auditor’s belief that maybe they’re mistaken, is sufficient to overcome their statement that they made under oath?”

Liss-Riordan maintained that the auditor’s counsel did not believe the Senate and wished for an expansive discovery to search for possible settlements.

Deakin said he would potentially consider allowing a limited discovery on specific questions, including what constitutes an official budget, but that the question may only matter after ruling on constitutionality. If he finds the law unconstitutional, the topic of the four types of documents will be inherently moot, he said.

“It doesn’t make sense to resolve the mootness issue ahead of the constitutional issue,” he said.

DiZoglio said the constitutional question is ultimately more important than whether the Senate complied with any individual document request.

The question of whether the Senate actually provided all four categories of records remains unresolved. So does whether the House must produce any documents at all.

“The Senate demonstrated at today’s hearing that it has voluntarily provided all of the specific documents the Auditor requested,” Senate President Karen Spilka said in a Tuesday afternoon statement.

For taxpayers, DiZoglio argued, the details matter because lump-sum spending figures do not reveal who received public money or whether contracts were awarded properly.

“Every dollar counts, every cent counts, right?” she said. “It’s your tax dollars.”

Sam Drysdale is a reporter for State House News Service and State Affairs Pro Massachusetts. Reach her at sdrysdale@statehousenews.com.